This photo is a visual representation of my frustration at only being able to scratch the surface of a much bigger need. |
Knock. Knock.
Who's there?
Utterly useless.
Utterly useless . . . who?
ME . . . that's who!
That's how I felt yesterday when a couple in great need walked into the church, and I wasn't able to do anything for them other than surface level band aid fixes. And, it's not just this isolated incident because I've felt this way before when someone comes for help and I can't really do much for them. And, it's not that I expect to be able to help everybody but rather it's a feeling of impotence in circumstances where I see suffering. And, I recognize that it's also not solely my or society's responsibility, it's the person in need as well . . . but they are often feeling utterly useless, too.
Every person in need has their own story. As for the couple that came into the church yesterday, their story was heart wrenching. Well, it wrenched my heart anyway. They're both unemployed, and one of them is on disability. They come from a rough neighbourhood, and found themselves in the midst of a local conflict. A few days ago some people broke into where they were staying . . . he caught a crowbar with his temple, she received boots to the face, and they escaped with the clothes on their back while their place was destroyed. For the last few nights they've slept outside, but now the weather has turned cold. They have no identification, no money, no food, and no place to stay.
Sure, their story may be fabricated and they may have had a greater role to play in their plight than they are letting on. All I know is their bruises were certainly real and they looked like death warmed over. Their smell was real, too. I have no doubt that somewhere along the road they made some poor choices. I know this because (a) we all make poor choices from time to time; (b) having talked with them for an hour I got the real sense that she suffered from fetal alcohol syndrome; and (c) neither of them were the sharpest knives in the drawer. But so what?!? What does it matter if their story is not 100% true or if they were authors of their own demise? Does that mean that they should be sentenced to homelessness and starvation? Even hardened criminals get a roof over their heads and a proper diet provided for them. (For more on this line of thought see "Cruel & Unusual Punishment".)
All I could do was spot them $10 to buy something to eat, make sure they had an appointment with the local agency who could potentially hook them up with temporary accommodation and food coupons, give them a ride to get some food, and then drop them at the local agency. Some will say that I did more than I had to, or at least more than most would. However, I had no doubt that this couple was in the midst of personal tragedy, and my efforts paled in comparison to the need. It could be that eight hours later they would be hungry again and sleeping outside if they were not successful getting the help they need from the local agency. The husband was really concerned that their lack of identification and the fact they were a visible minority from a rough neighbourhood would prevent them from getting the help they needed. Shaking his head as we were driving he commented, almost to himself, "I'm not a bad person. Just in a bad situation."
It is because of the number of different stories resulting in poverty and the fact the average person is not equipped to deal with most of them that we need to have a collective strategy to deal with poverty. We need better government and professional involvement in order to properly address the various faces of poverty. We need enhanced legislative support to ensure things like living wages and protection of rights. We need coordination of efforts by organizations equipped to address the variety of needs involved. We need to make poverty eradication a priority in order to get to the root causes, and not just be satisfied with band aid treatment of symptoms.
Nobody . . . not those in need . . . not you or I trying to help . . . should ever feel utterly useless. Let's unite and support the changes necessary so it doesn't happen any more.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Phase II - Struggles of the Working Poor Daily
Report
Day 71 - 72 (January 10th – January 11th)
Day 71 - 72 (January 10th – January 11th)
Weight at Beginning of Project: 233 lbs
Weight at End of Phase One: 216 lbs
Weight at Start of Phase Two: 221 lbs
Weight at Start of Today: 218 lbs
Available Funds: $30.85 (leftover)
+ $5.00 (Jan 10) + $9.00 (Jan 11) = $44.85Weight at End of Phase One: 216 lbs
Weight at Start of Phase Two: 221 lbs
Weight at Start of Today: 218 lbs
Funds Spent Today: $11.70
Remaining Funds: $33.15
New Loan: $0.00 (Jan 3)
Loan Payment Due Today: $0.00
Loan Payment: $0.00
Outstanding Loan: $50.00 (originally $50.00 on Jan 3) @ 3% per month (non-compounding) = $50.50 Owing as at Jan 11th . . . full re-payment due January 31st (or earlier)
Items Purchased: Sesame Snack (from health store), $10 Given to Couple in Need
Free Stuff: Nil Loan Payment Due Today: $0.00
Loan Payment: $0.00
Outstanding Loan: $50.00 (originally $50.00 on Jan 3) @ 3% per month (non-compounding) = $50.50 Owing as at Jan 11th . . . full re-payment due January 31st (or earlier)
Items Purchased: Sesame Snack (from health store), $10 Given to Couple in Need
Gas Purchased* & Remaining: $0.00 (i.e.
0.00 litres @ $1.109 per litre . . . 0.0 km @ 10 km/litre) + 3.16 litres (gas
remaining) = 3.16 litres (31.6 km)
Driving Today: 19.0 km (i.e. 1.90 litres)
Gas Remaining: 1.26 litres (i.e. 12.6 km)
*Will not include
any fuel or driving related to work that is paid for by work.Driving Today: 19.0 km (i.e. 1.90 litres)
Gas Remaining: 1.26 litres (i.e. 12.6 km)
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Hey!! I'm That Poverty Guy . . . let's make a world of difference together.
Click Here to See WHAT YOU CAN DO
Click Here to Sign . . . A Declaration to World Leaders
I am really enjoying your blog and following your progress in the Poverty Project (since I first heard about you a month or so ago). Well done and I hope your message is making waves! With regards to today's post, I have also had similar feelings in my life and work. It's one of the reasons that I feel the way you do about poverty and how much things need to change. Anyway, I keep a quote from Mother Teresa close to me that helps somewhat: "We can do no great things, only small things with great love." It really helps me when I feel so powerless; your love and compassion for these folks is something and it mattered to them and to all of us. Thank you.
ReplyDeleteThanks very much for your encouragement and following along. I REALLY appreciate your reminder of Mother Teresa's words. Thank YOU!
DeleteYou could have been the start of a change...you were planted in their path for a reason...and the words you shared...you have no idea!!!! it could have really given them the evidence that SOME people still do care in this world! perhaps u planted the seed....sowers are just as important as pruners!!!! (plus...it sounds like you did all you could at this point.)
ReplyDeleteYou're right, of course. None of us know the depth of the impact that we have on the lives of others with even the simplest of acts. That said, from time to time we will each feel the frustration of not being able to do enough. In those situations it's important we step back and remember the advice you have given as well as the comment of the Reluctant Gardener (above). Then, we can dust off the frustration, take a deep breath, and keep on caring. :)
DeleteYou kind of said it yourself, but knowing you, I'm not sure that you believe it...'you did as much and more than even God would have expected you to do under the severe circumstances.' Look at you, living on a strict budget and you gave them $10. That's a whole day's food ration to you so how much more could you have given in that way. Then you listened to them...not for 10 minutes but for an hour...and probably made them feel visible and more worthy than they had felt in a long time, if ever. You went out of your way to give them a ride and to make an appointment for them to get some help. I would be curious to know what you felt you didn't do given all the circumstances. You walked your talk and expecting so much more of yourself in this situation may make others feel kind of hopeless in how much they can give. You went the extra, extra, extra mile to help two of your fellow beings and I will bet that they will never forget you. I think you should be gentler with yourself, Sean. You are a good and Christian man...in the very best definition of that word...who deserves as much kindness as he gives to others. Job well done, Sean.
ReplyDeleteWow . . . thanks for these kinds words. Very much appreciated.
DeleteJust to be clear, I'm not bummed out by this incident still as the feeling really was "temporary". And, I certainly don't want anyone to think that giving even if it doesn't solve the bigger problem is futile. Doing even little things for others can do wonders for people that we don't even know, plant seeds for the future, provide encouragement, etc. However, I was speaking to the real and natural possibility that someone does all they can do (which, I agree I did) and then feel it is insignicant in the circumstances and greatness of the need. I just want everyone to know that it's alright to feel like that sometimes as it shows you care . . . as long as you move on and channel that energy to continuing to help when you get the opportunity rather than closing yourself off.
When I'm in these utterly useless positions, I offer what I can, which is sometimes nothing more than a blessing or well wish. In return, I have really appreciated the thought of others who offer me the same, when they have nothing else to offer. Mysterian (Phoenix)
DeleteVery wise words. Thanks so much for posting your comment.
Delete